
COLUMBUS — Nebraska hasn’t beaten a ranked team since Sept. 17, 2016, against No. 22 Oregon. It has been 31 straight losses to Top 25 teams since then for the Cornhuskers, including seven against the Ohio State.
Those Nebraska losses to the Buckeyes:
• No. 7 Ohio State in 2016
• No. 9 Ohio State in 2017
• No. 10 Ohio State in 2018
• No. 5 Ohio State in 2019
• No. 5 Ohio State in 2020
• No. 5 Ohio State in 2021
• No. 4 Ohio State in 2024
Now Nebraska hosts No. 14 Ohio State in Memorial Stadium on Saturday at noon. What’s going to happen? Time for game theories.
Game theory from Bill
Pick: Ohio State 24, Nebraska 17
There’s a little too much enthusiasm for Nebraska pulling off the type of upset it hasn’t shown an ability to pull off in a decade, but there are things to worry about here. It starts with Nebraska quarterback Anthony Colandrea’s legs. Ohio State hasn’t seen a running quarterback like this. It hasn’t seen the volume of designed quarterback run that it’s bound to face in this game. The Buckeyes have struggled with two-back run concepts this year, and if you consider Colandrea a second running back (you should), then I’m at least on alert for Matt Patricia’s unit having some issues containing the quarterback run.
The question is whether Colandrea’s legs prove to be a minor nuisance at times, or the reason that Nebraska pulls off the upset.
I’m leaning toward the former.
After cutting it loose with the defensive front last week against Northwestern, which led to five sacks, I’m expecting a game plan that focuses more on keeping Colandrea in the pocket, where he’s less dangerous. The matchups at the skill spots should favor the Buckeyes. As long as they don’t let the quarterback run crazy, the OSU defense should be in decent shape. You’ll need a spy here. It’ll be a big moment for Riley Pettijohn.
Offensively, Ohio State caught a break on Wednesday night when it was revealed that Nebraska will be without arguably its three most important defenders: its best defensive back, its green dot linebacker, and its best pass rusher.
This will be a different road test than what Luke Fahey faced in his first road start at USC. It wasn’t very loud in that game, and yet the Buckeyes had some procedural issues. If those happen again here, and OSU gets off-schedule, it could be a tough day converting against the country’s best third-down defense. Staying on schedule will be key, which is why I’m expecting an elevated rushing rate for Ohio State. Bo Jackson and Isaiah West will churn out enough 4-6 yard runs to keep Fahey in manageable third downs.
Against a short-handed secondary, Jeremiah Smith will have one of those prolific days that positions him as an even stronger Heisman Trophy favorite heading into the last week of the regular season.
Game theory from subscriber Mario D from Fort Lauderdale, Fla.
Pick: Ohio State 27, Nebraska 17
There’s a gleam, men. There’s a gleam. Let’s get the gleam …
Being a Browns fan, one of my guilty pleasures is YouTubing nostalgic NFL Films clips of the Browns of yesteryear, when the team was far more successful on the field and a lot less of an abomination off the field. This certainly isn’t a unique indulgent pleasure specific to myself as a Browns fan; rather, I suspect that many of my fellow BAD Subscriber brethren suffer from similar postmodern impulses that can only be satiated by grainy, nostalgic sports clips.
Now, some of you might be confused by a Cleveland Browns reference at the top of this column (and for you Bengals fans, perhaps an expletive or two tumbled out of your mouth after the first couple sentences). I begin this column with a Browns reference and, specifically, a quote from the late, great Marty Schottenheimer, because it is these words that have played on loop in my mind since Ohio State’s 28-19 win over Northwestern last Saturday, and the continued football chaos that ensued throughout the rest of Saturday evening and into Sunday.
I mean, what further evidence does one need of this year’s college football chaos — and potential playoff possibilities — than an SEC game having to be rescheduled and played on a day that belongs solely, and almost exclusively, to the NFL? When chaos ensues, anything can happen.
There’s a gleam …
Then Tuesday night’s playoff rankings came out, where the Buckeyes miraculously moved up six spots from No. 20 to No. 14, keeping the door wide open for a potential playoff berth this season.
There’s a gleam …
Last Saturday’s game showed the Buckeyes making strides on the offensive line and landing on a mixture of the familiar (Austin Siereveld at left tackle) and the foreign (Jake Cook at left guard, Ian Moore at right tackle.) This unit held its own against a so-so Northwestern defense and, as a glass-half-full kind of guy, it gives me hope that this offensive line combination will bring consistency and aggression against a stout Nebraska defense this Saturday.
There’s a gleam …
Last Saturday’s win over Northwestern was once again exemplary of Ryan Day reengineering and simplifying his coordinator’s defense, settling on a scheme that favored this year’s defensive roster and not the Silver Bullets of yesteryear (i.e., last year).
Nebraska quarterback Anthony Colandrea will certainly test last week’s schematic changes, especially through his ability to run and extend plays, but I expect the Buckeyes to stack good back-to-back defensive performances this Saturday. I also expect the defensive line to continue last week’s success by once again adding to the team’s season sack total.
Do I have any data points to lend credence or support to this prediction? Absolutely not. Only chaos.
There’s a gleam …
Then there is the majesty of Jeremiah Smith. Coming into this season, I told myself that no matter what happens, I should appreciate this season because I’ve been blessed to live in the same timeline as the Buckeyes junior receiver (this last sentence probably reads a bit hyperbolic; for honesty’s sake, I also once said the same thing about David Bowie shortly after his passing).
After Ohio State’s disastrous loss to Oregon, the team was down, the fanbase was down, and we could all sense Smith’s Heisman chances slipping away. Just two short weeks later, the Greatest Buckeye Ever is the odds-on favorite to win the Heisman Trophy, exactly twenty years after another Smith wearing a Buckeye jersey won it in 2006. I am predicting Jeremiah Smith to have a 100-yard, multiple-touchdown game, continuing his march towards winning this year’s Triple Crown (Big Ten Receiver of the Year, Biletnikoff Winner, Heisman Trophy Winner).
There’s a gleam …
Finally, our other starting quarterback from Southern California, whose grandparents met while attending Ohio State in the 1950s (because of course they did), continued to make strides at the position last week against Northwestern. While Luke Fahey hasn’t been perfect, he has played well enough, in my opinion, to have won all three games he’s started this year. This Saturday, the lifelong Buckeye fan gets his first win on the road in Lincoln, Nebraska, keeping the Buckeyes playoff chances alive.
Let’s get the gleam.
Game theory from Doug
Pick: Ohio State 24, Nebraska 13
We talked about this clip in the chat enough this week that I asked Ryan Day about it on Wednesday night. This video created by the Ohio State video team from the win over Northwestern includes freshman quarterback Luke Fahey working his way through every offensive position group on the sideline after a touchdown, encouraging them to keep it going.
“Way to lead, kid, way to lead,” center Carson Hinzman tells Fahey.
The 1.0 version of Luke Fahey is over. The 2.0 version debuts Saturday.
“He’s the type of guy that sits down at the poker table, he’s probably going to end up with the most chips,” Ryan Day said in part about Fahey.
I criticized the over-moxification of Fahey in the past, because I thought people were assuming his personality trait was going to make up for everything else working against Fahey — inexperience and size, primarily.
But I’m interested in that clip, and in Day’s answer, because I’m curious about the best version of what Fahey can be right now. If he’s working his teammates like that, I think we’re there.
After Oregon beat Ohio State, Ducks coach Dan Lanning said he looked at Ryan Day that week and said to his team that’s where he had been two weeks earlier, searching for answers after a starting quarterback injury.
“It’s hard really to overcome, because what you do in those moments, you just try harder and harder and harder to fix things and you can’t fix everything,” Lanning said. “I know it’s hard when you change what you think you’re going to be throughout the year, and somebody gets injured. It takes a while to kind of figure that out. And in college football, you just don’t have time to do that.
“We had some learning pains, went through some growing pains ourselves of figuring out, OK, how do we become the team that we want to be? And I feel like we saw glimpses of that tonight.”
Lanning said that after beating the Buckeyes in Oregon’s fifth game after their injury to starting QB Dante Moore. But it was only the fourth game of Dylan Raiola starting for the Ducks, because they had detoured away from Raiola into Brock Thomas for one QB start.
Saturday is Fahey’s fourth start. There’s no reason the Buckeyes shouldn’t be ready to find themselves the way the Ducks found themselves in Columbus.
That’s my primary theory — the emergence of what the real Fahey-led Buckeyes can look like this season.
While Ohio State has lost to USC and Oregon and beaten Northwestern the last three weeks, Nebraska has been one of the few Big Ten teams with a healthy QB, but they’ve created problems for themselves.
In the last three weeks, in offensive success rate, Nebraska is No. 27 nationally and Ohio State is No. 33. In defensive success rate, Ohio State is No. 26 and Nebraska is No. 36. That’s pretty even.
But Ohio State should be trending up. Nebraska, with three major defensive injuries, should be trending down.
Even look at one of the things Nebraska does best — scoring touchdowns in the red zone. The Cornhuskers have the best red-zone TD rate in the nation at 81.8 percent.
The last three weeks, there are 0 for 1 against Washington, 1 for 1 against Illinois and 4 for 4 against the high school team that is Rutgers. They managed just two red-zone trips in two losses to Washington and Illinois?
Ohio State, with a new QB, over those three games is 1 for 4, 4 for 4 and 4 for 6 on red-zone TDs.
So last three games total, red-zone TDs, Nebraska is 5 for 6 and Ohio State is 9 for 14. Nice percentage for Nebraska, but one red zone trip won’t cut it Saturday. Not as Fahey and the Buckeyes are figuring it out.


Excellent column. Thanks to Mario, Doug, and Bill. There is a gleam and I am here for it.
Watch the Wash-Neb tape. UW defense a lot like the Buckeyes—weak pass rush, strong in the back end. UW just held their spaces on pass plays and kept Colandro in the pocket and made him throw. They had 3 picks. Matty P should learn from that game. Buckeyes 27, Huskers 13